Official recommendation
FIND based on substantial evidence in the record there is the potential for significant impacts resulting from the unique circumstances of the property being located on an active landslide area in the Palisades burn area. RESOLVE TO GRANT THE APPEAL filed by Castellammare Mesa Home Owners Association (Representative: Kristina Kropp, Luna & Glushon), and THEREBY OVERTURN the determination of the West Los Angeles Area Planning Commission (WLAAPC) in approving a Mitigated Negative Declaration, Mitigation Monitoring Program and Errata, as the environmental clearance for the development to occur on 12 existing lots, comprising four separate sites. The project consists of the construction of four single-family dwellings on each site, one detached Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), swimming pools, decks, retaining walls, grading necessary for the residential development, remedial grading, and a 200-foot extension of Revello Drive with required grading, total grading for the project consists of approximately 29,148 cubic yards of earthwork, of which 28,341 cubic yards will be remedial, and a Haul Route approval for the export of 33,794 cubic yards of dirt, the project includes a 200-foot extension of Revello Drive; for the construction of a new two-story 9,051 square-foot single family residence with a 5,887 square-foot basement, a new pool/spa with attached garage, decks, two new retaining walls, each with a maximum height of 10 feet, landscaping and hardscaping improvements, trellises, and an ADU, for the properties located at 17538 - 17550 Tramonto Drive (Case No. DIR-2019- 6352-CDP-MEL-1A, SHP House 1); construction of a new two-story 4,160 square-foot single-family residence with a 5,096 square-foot basement, a new pool/spa with attached garage, decks, two new retaining walls, each with a maximum height of 10 feet, landscaping and hardscaping improvements and trellises, for the properties located at 17532 - 17548 Revello Drive (Case Nos. DIR-2019-5524-CDP-MEL-1A and ZA-2019- 5525-ZAD-1A, SHP House 2); construction of a new two-story 2,619 square-foot single-family residence with a 2,428 square-foot basement, a new pool/spa with attached garage, decks, two new retaining walls, each with a maximum height of 10 feet, landscaping and hardscaping improvements and trellises, for properties located at 17523 - 17529 Revello Drive (Case Nos. DIR-2019-5571-CDP-MEL-1A and ZA-2019-5574-ZAD-1A, JDR House 1); and construction of a new two-story 5,645 square-foot single-family residence with a 6,292 square- foot basement, a new pool/spa with attached garage, decks, two new retaining walls, each with a maximum height of 10 feet, landscaping and hardscaping improvements and trellises, for properties located at 17533 - 17547 Revello Drive (Case Nos. DIR- 2019-5584-CDP-MEL-1A and ZA-2019-5585-ZAD-1A, JDR House 2). REMAND the the environmental analysis to the WLAAPC; and INSTRUCT the Department of City Planning (DCP) to prepare a new environmental clearance that complies with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and is supported with substantial evidence, including potentially a site specific Environmental Impact Report (EIR), to analyze the unique conditions of the project site being located in an active landslide in a wildfire burn area consistent with Council District 11’s statement and transmit the new CEQA clearance to the WLAAPC for its consideration along with its reconsideration of the project in light of any new CEQA clearance prepared for the project; and further instruct the DCP to consult with the Bureau of Engineering and the Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety to evaluate whether the developer and/or future developers should be required to contribute to a thorough, city-led assessment of the Castellammare landslide, as recommended by Council District 11, in the Communication – Recommended Findings, dated December 2, 2024, attached to the Council file. Applicant: Springhouse Hamilton Park LLC (SHP House 1 & 2); JDR Revello LLC (JDR House 1 & 2); Demos Development (all four houses) Representative: Greg Demos, Demos Development and Tony Russo, Crest Real Estate Case Nos. DIR-2019-6352-CDP-MEL-1A; DIR-2019-5524-CDP-MEL- 1A; DIR-2019-5571-CDP-MEL-1A; DIR-2019-5584-CDP-MEL-1A; ZA-2019-5525-ZAD-1A; ZA-2019-5574-ZAD-1A; ZA-2019-5585-ZAD-1A Environmental No. ENV-2019-5520-MND-1A Fiscal Impact Statement: The WLAAPC reports that there is no General Fund impact as administrative costs are recovered through fees. Community Impact Statement: None submitted Report from Planning and Land Use Management Committee_5-27-25 Communication(s) from Public_5-27-25 Returned Envelopes_5-27-25 Communication(s) from Public_5-26-25 Communication(s) from Public_5-25-25 Communication(s) from Public_5-24-25 Communication(s) from Public_5-23-25 Returned Envelopes_5-14-25 Communication from Committee Clerk - Notice_5-02-25 Returned Envelopes_1-08-25 Returned Envelopes_12-19-24 Speaker Card(s)_12-03-2024 Communication from Council District 11_ 12-2-24 Communication(s) from Public_12-02-2024 Communication from Council District 11 - Recommended Findings_12-2-24 Communication(s) from Public_12-02-2024 Communication(s) from Public_12-02-24 Communication(s) from Public_12-02-24 Communication(s) from Public_12-01-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-30-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-29-2024 Communication(s) from Public_11-27-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-27-2024 Communication(s) from Public_11-27-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-26-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-25-24 Communication(s) from Public_11-24-24 Returned Envelopes_11-22-24 Communication from Committee Clerk - Notice_11-08-24 Communication from Department of City Planning dated 10-30-24 - Supplemental Transmittal Communication from Applicant Representative - Consent to Time Limit Extension_7-23-24 Communication from Applicant Representative - Consent to Time Limit Extension_5-16-24 Communication(s) from Public_05-15-2024 Speaker Card(s)_05-07-2024 Communication(s) from Public_05-07-2024 Communication(s) from Public_05-01-2024 Communication from Department of City Planning dated 5-02-24 - Supplemental Transmittal Attachment to Communication dated 5-02-24 - Appeal Response Communication from Appellant Representative_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 1_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 2_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 3_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 4_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 5_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 6_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 7_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 8_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 9_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 10_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 11_4-30-24 Communication from Appellant - Attachment 12_4-30-24 Returned Mail_4-29-24 Communication(s) from Public_4-29-24 Returned Mail_4-24-24 Communication from Committee Clerk - Notice_4-12-24 Communication from City Planning dated 4-10-24 - Supplemental Transmittal Attachment to Communication dated 4-10-24 - Mailing List Attachment to Communication dated 4-10-24 - Email List Report from West Los Angeles Area Planning Commission dated 3-19-24 Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Appeal Justification Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Conditions of Approval Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Findings Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Appeal Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Letter of Determination Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - MND and Errata Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Environmental Study.pdf Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Staff Report.pdf Attachment to Report dated 3-19-24 - Interested Parties Communication(s) from Public_05-19-2025 Communication(s) from Public_05-27-2025 Communication(s) from Public_05-27-2025 Speaker Card(s)_05-27-2025 Communication(s) from Public_05-29-2025